AI Labor Tracker
The Seattle Times Newsroom Union Offered to Let AI Take Over Jobs Left Open by Retirements and Departures. Management Still Refused to Rule Out Layoffs Caused by AI.
The difference between 'no layoffs' and 'no staff reduction' is one clause, and it's where most AI replacement will happen. Across the economy, people quit almost twice as often as they're laid off. A union that protects only the people in the chairs leaves the chairs themselves on the table.
37.6M
37.6 million quits vs 20.8 million layoffs and discharges, US, Oct 2025 to Sep 2026 (BLS JOLTS, our sum of monthly figures)
The Seattle Times newsroom union went into a bargaining session with an offer it called “a significant potential concession,” according to an update its bargaining committee posted on Nov. 10. The union had been asking for contract language saying the use of artificial intelligence couldn’t result in a “staff reduction” of anyone in the bargaining unit. It offered to narrow that to “layoff.”
The change “directly addressed an argument management had previously made,” wrote Alexandra Yoon-Hendricks, who posted the union’s update: “That they want the ability to backfill vacated jobs with AI, if necessary.”
Management said no anyway, the union wrote. Head of HR Martin Hammond said the company doesn’t plan to lay off journalists and replace them with AI, according to the update, but “we don’t want to restrict ourselves. We want the right to keep navigating a tough industry.”
That’s one newspaper and one session, described by one side. I’m treating it that way. But the two words on the table, “layoff” and “staff reduction,” are the clearest statement I’ve seen of where the fight over AI and jobs actually sits.
Two words, two different protections
Here’s the plain version. A clause that bans AI-driven layoffs protects the people in the jobs right now. A clause that bans AI-driven staff reduction protects the jobs themselves.
The gap between those two is everyone who leaves on their own. When a reporter retires, takes a job somewhere else or moves away, a “no layoffs” clause lets the employer decide not to hire a replacement and hand the work to software. A “no staff reduction” clause doesn’t.
The union’s offer, in its own words, would “give the company flexibility to make adjustments when members retire or leave the company.” In other words, it offered to let AI shrink the newsroom through attrition, as long as nobody currently in a chair got pushed out of it. And the company still wanted to keep the option of layoffs too.
Hammond’s quote is worth reading closely. He said there’s no plan to lay off journalists and replace them with AI. That may be completely true. A company can mean it and still refuse to write it down, because a contract outlasts a plan. From management’s side, the reasoning is simple: nobody knows what the tools will do in three years, and a newspaper’s finances aren’t getting easier.
From the newsroom’s side, the reasoning is just as simple. A promise that isn’t in the contract is a forecast.
Why the attrition clause is the one that matters
To see why the union fought over “staff reduction” first, look at how people actually leave jobs in America.
The Bureau of Labor Statistics counts separations every month in its Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey. From October 2025 through September 2026, US employers recorded about 37.6 million quits, by my sum of the monthly figures. Layoffs and discharges came to about 20.8 million. Another 3.8 million or so were “other separations,” which include retirements. [Chart: quits vs layoffs and discharges, 12 months to Sep 2026, BLS JOLTS.]
So across the economy, people walked out on their own almost twice as often as they were pushed. In September alone, quits ran at about 3.4 million against 1.6 million layoffs and discharges, per BLS.
Now think like a manager with an AI tool that can do part of a job. You don’t need a layoff. You need a resignation letter and a decision not to post the opening. At those turnover rates, a team can get a lot smaller in a few years without a single pink slip. And none of it shows up in layoff trackers.
That’s the pattern I’ve been writing about all fall. Deferred hiring and buyouts don’t make headlines. They’re how most of the change happens.
The honest wrinkle in newspapers
I want to be fair about one thing that cuts against my own argument. Newspapers sit in the information industry, and that industry hasn’t looked like the rest of the economy lately.
In information, layoffs and discharges have actually run ahead of quits. Over the year to September, BLS counted about 558,000 layoffs and discharges in the sector against about 431,000 quits. In September, the layoff rate was 1.7% of employment and the quit rate 1.4%.
So a journalist has more reason to fear the layoff than the average worker does. That cuts both ways for the union’s offer. It makes the narrowed “no layoffs” clause more valuable to members than it would be in, say, retail. And it means the company, in giving up layoffs, would have been giving up a tool it actually uses.
Even so, quits in the information sector added up to about 15% of employment over the year, if you add up the monthly rates. Some people quit more than once, so treat that as a rough guide. It’s still a lot of empty chairs for software to sit in.
Other unions are drawing the same line in different places
The Seattle Times isn’t alone. This week brought a small cluster of contracts and proposals that show where unions are drawing their lines on AI.
In Long Beach, California, members of IAM Local 1930 ratified a contract with the city that limits the use of AI in discipline, the union announced on Nov. 10. The city’s proposed 2027 budget had called for cutting 367 jobs: 158 vacant positions and 209 filled ones, the union said. The city agreed to largely shrink its workforce by not filling vacancies and through normal attrition. Those cuts were about the budget, not AI. But they show attrition is the tool employers and unions both reach for when headcount has to fall, because it’s the one that doesn’t hurt anyone currently on payroll.
At the University of Washington, SEIU 925, which represents workers at the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation, proposed that “employees’ use or non-use of AI shall not be used as a metric for evaluating employee performance,” according to the university’s own bargaining recap. The union also proposed that the employer “may encourage but not mandate” generative AI use, and that it not rely on generative AI in employment decisions. Those are proposals, not agreements. The next session is Nov. 18.
At Yale, the clerical and technical workers of UNITE HERE Local 34 say AI guardrails will be a top priority when their contract expires in January, the Yale Daily News reported on Nov. 11. Their current agreement requires 90 days’ notice before new technology that “may be reasonably be expected to result in” substantial changes to jobs, the paper reported, and the union argues Yale broke that rule when it rolled out its Clarity chatbot. That’s the union’s allegation.
And earlier this month, City College of San Francisco put language on the table about bargaining the effects of technology, which I wrote about on Tuesday.
Put those side by side and you get a rough map. Some unions are fighting over evaluation and discipline. Some are fighting over notice. Some are fighting over layoffs. Only the Seattle Times union, as far as I can tell from what’s public, opened by fighting over the total number of jobs, and then offered to give that up.
What the company is protecting
I don’t think the Times is being villainous here. Newspapers have been shrinking for two decades, and a publisher that signs away the right to use a new tool to stay solvent is betting the paper on a forecast too.
But I’d point out what the company’s position reveals. If management truly had no intention of reducing staff through AI, the “staff reduction” clause would cost it nothing. The company argued instead that it wanted the ability to backfill vacated jobs with AI. Then, when offered exactly that, it still wanted to keep layoffs open.
That tells you the company sees real value in using AI to change headcount, even if there’s no plan today. And that’s information the reporters can use. Management’s own argument tells you which jobs they think software might do.
Why severance sits in the same package
There’s a reason the union bundled AI with wages and severance in one set of proposals, as its update describes. They’re the same question asked three ways.
Think about it from first principles. An employer that wants fewer people has three doors. It can wait for people to leave and not replace them, which costs nothing up front and makes no news. It can offer buyouts, which cost money but are voluntary. Or it can lay people off, which costs severance, may trigger legal notice rules for larger cuts, and lands in the paper. Every employer prefers the first door when it has time.
A “no AI staff reduction” clause closes the first door for AI. A “no AI layoff” clause closes the third. Severance is the price of the third door when it stays open. So if the company keeps the right to AI-driven layoffs, the union’s next best protection is making those layoffs expensive. That’s why the three issues travel together, and why I’d expect the final deal to trade one against another.
The company’s refusal of even the narrow clause means the severance terms may end up doing the work the AI clause was meant to do.
Quits lead layoffs in the whole economy, not in newspapers' industry
Sum of twelve monthly JOLTS figures, October 2025 to September 2026.
How to read thisEach panel starts at zero. Teal is quits across all industries. Information is the exception, and its marks are rates, not counts.
37.6M
quits, October 2025 to September 2026. Layoffs and discharges were 20.8 million.
Bar chart. Use the up and down arrow keys to move through 4 categories. A data table follows.
Quits, all industries: Separations 37,568
- 37568 thousand is 37.6 million. 20799 thousand is 20.8 million. September 2026 is preliminary.
Figure 1. All-industry figures are thousands of separations. Information figures are a percent of employment. 37568 thousand is 37.6 million. 20799 thousand is 20.8 million.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, JOLTS, seasonally adjusted, retrieved Nov 12, 2026. Chart: Post Labor Economics Download CSV Methodology
Data table
Sums of monthly levels and of monthly rates. A sum of rates is not a count of people.
| item | Separations |
|---|---|
| Quits, all industries | 37,568 |
| Layoffs and discharges, all industries | 20,799 |
| Quits, information | 15.2 |
| Layoffs and discharges, information | 20.1 |
My read
In my opinion, the union was right to fight over “staff reduction” first, and right to understand what it was giving up when it narrowed it.
A layoff ban protects the people in the room. An attrition ban protects the next reporter, the one who would have been hired when today’s veteran retires. Unions bargain for current members, so it makes sense they’d trade the second for the first. But that’s the trade that lets AI hollow out a workplace slowly and quietly, one unfilled opening at a time.
I’d also say this is the kind of change that’s hardest to see from outside. A newsroom that goes from 100 people to 80 through attrition never shows up in a layoff count. It looks like nothing happened, and the paper covering itself won’t call it news.
The limit on my argument: I have only the union’s account of the session. The company’s view, as quoted, is short. If the Times publishes its own summary or the contract is settled, I’ll update this.
What happens next
The union’s update says the bargaining and mobilizing committees are reaching out to every member for feedback after members “overwhelmingly disapproved” of the company’s latest offer in a recent survey. Hammond, per the union, said the company won’t make another wage offer until both sides are close to settling everything. So AI, wages and severance are tied together now, in one package.
My recommendation, for any worker whose contract is about to talk about AI: read the verb. “Layoff,” “terminate,” “displace,” “reduce staff” and “eliminate positions” are not the same promise. Ask whether the language covers jobs that open up when people leave. That’s where most of the change will come from, and it’s the clause your employer will fight hardest to keep out.
Chart note: Quits vs layoffs and discharges, United States, October 2025 to September 2026. Measure: sum of 12 monthly JOLTS levels, in thousands; information-sector panel also shows sums of monthly rates as a percent of employment. Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, JOLTS, seasonally adjusted, retrieved Nov 12, 2026. September 2026 figures preliminary. CSV: jolts-quits-vs-layoffs-2026.csv.
Sources
- Seattle Times Union, Alexandra Yoon-Hendricks, “Bargaining Update 10/27: More AI discussion as neogitations inch forward” (title as published), posted Nov 10, 2026. https://www.seattletimesunion.com/updates/bargaining-update-1027-more-ai-discussion-as-neogitations-inch-forward (layoff vs staff reduction proposal; “directly addressed an argument management had previously made”; backfill quote; “significant potential concession”; Hammond quotes; “overwhelmingly disapproved”; wage-offer timing).
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, JOLTS, seasonally adjusted, retrieved Nov 12, 2026 via BLS API. Series JTS000000000000000QUL, JTS000000000000000LDL, JTS000000000000000OSL, JTS510000000000000QUL, JTS510000000000000LDL, JTS510000000000000QUR, JTS510000000000000LDR. https://www.bls.gov/jlt/
- IAM Union, “IAM Local 1930 Long Beach City Workers Ratify Strong Contract After Robust Internal Organizing Campaign,” Nov 10, 2026. https://www.goiam.org/news/iam-local-1930-long-beach-city-workers-ratify-strong-contract-after-robust-internal-organizing-campaign/ (AI in discipline limits; 367 proposed cuts, 158 vacant and 209 filled; attrition agreement).
- University of Washington Labor Relations, “UW IHME & SEIU 925 Negotiations Recap for October 27 and November 5, 2026,” last updated Nov 9, 2026. https://hr.uw.edu/labor/2026/11/05/uw-ihme-seiu-925-negotiations-recap-for-october-27-and-november-5-2026 (union proposals on AI and evaluation; “may encourage but not mandate”; next session Nov 18).
- Yale Daily News, Evelyn Ronan, “Yale clerical workers’ union to seek AI guardrails in upcoming contract,” Nov 11, 2026. https://yaledailynews.com/articles/yale-clerical-workers-union-to-seek-ai-guardrails-in-upcoming-contract (contract expires January; 90-day technological change notice; Clarity; union allegation of breach).
- Post Labor Economics, earlier pieces: https://postlaboreconomics.com/posts/ccsf-ai-bargaining-effects-not-jobs/ ; https://postlaboreconomics.com/posts/buyouts-dont-show-up-in-layoff-counts/ ; https://postlaboreconomics.com/posts/gartner-net-jobs-mostly-tech/
Derived values (our arithmetic): 12-month sums Oct 2025 to Sep 2026: quits 37,568K, layoffs and discharges 20,799K (ratio 1.81, “almost twice”), other separations 3,798K; information quits 431K vs layoffs 558K; information quit-rate sum 15.2% (“about 15%”).